I finished Mornings with Henri J.M. Nouwen. I started reading Helmut Thielicke’s Out of the Depths. Thielicke was my dad’s favorite theologian (who is yours?) I could never get into Thielicke growing up. Very dry. Dense. German. But I started reading the first sermon. I am gleaning appreciation.
He wrote in the time of World War 2. Growing up Germany was always the enemy. I never looked at the suffering as universal
“There are many among us who have lost everything and who will find it hard to erase from their minds the horror they have suffered and the collapse of their individual world. And even if they do, they cannot blot out the specific question which we see whenever we look into their wounded and tortured eyes, the question, “Why?”
“In all our misfortunes and catastrophes our deepest human instinct compels us to as who the guilty ones are… we have to raise the startling and insistent question, Why? An obscure feeling forces us to do so.”
“This little word “why” is no torrent of speech. It is only a little drop of three letters. Yet it can cause mortal injury to our souls.”
Thielicke points how (as a christian pastor) how Jesus as a teacher does not take the bait on the question why. Rather he answers “so that…” in order that” by putting the question in a larger context it liberates us from up/down good bad judgement and immerses us in part of a larger meaning and plan.